Free shipping on all U.S. orders · Tracked delivery FREE 30-DAY RETURNS · SECURE CHECKOUT · EMAIL SUPPORT

All products

Toy Gifts Under $25

Small gifts and stocking stuffers priced under $25: plush, fidgets, card games, craft kits, bath toys and mini building sets. Party supplies and replacement parts are left out so the page shows actual gifts, and only items currently in stock are listed. You'll find 1,488 toys from 898 brands, including Tonies, LEGO ...

Free shipping
Secure checkout
Free 30-day returns

Bedwina inflatable basketballs, 16-inch pack, ideal for pool games and parties.

Bedwina

Bedwina 16-Inch Inflatable Basketballs — Pack of 12 for Pool, Beach, and Party Fun

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Learning Resources Snap-n-Learn dinosaurs halves for color matching and fine motor development.

Learning Resources

Learning Resources Snap-n-Learn Matching Dinos – Colorful Two-Piece Dino Toys for Toddlers

$20.25

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

GUND Pusheen Snackable Sushi plush, soft 9.5-inch desk buddy for home or office

GUND

GUND Pusheen Snackable Sushi Plush – 9.5-Inch Soft Toy for Pusheen Fans

$23.00

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Melissa & Doug Race Car kit with wooden parts and wheels for imaginative play.

Melissa & Doug

Melissa & Doug Decorate-Your-Own Wooden Race Car & Monster Truck Kit

$24.40

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Melissa & Doug Flip Fish toy with squeaker tail encourages grasping and auditory play

Melissa & Doug

Melissa & Doug Flip Fish: Soft, Multi-Textured Baby Toy with Squeak, Crinkle & Mirror

$23.51

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

GUND My First Teddy Bear in soft plush, perfect for newborn cuddles and safe play.

GUND

GUND Baby My First Teddy Bear - Ultra-Soft 10” Plush for Newborns & Babies

$19.74

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Melissa & Doug milk carton for pretend grocery play and kitchen role-play.

Melissa & Doug

Melissa & Doug Fridge Fillers: 8-Piece Wooden Grocery Cartons for Pretend Play – FSC Certified

$23.24

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Melissa & Doug K's Kids Musical Farmyard Cube nose-press sounds for interactive play.

Melissa & Doug

Melissa & Doug K's Kids Musical Farmyard Cube – Interactive Baby Toy

$20.00

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Steve Jackson Games Munchkin 2 Unnatural Axe Orc race card for new strategies and chaos.

Steve Jackson Games

Steve Jackson Games Munchkin 2: Unnatural Axe – Orc Race Expansion (112 Cards)

$24.59

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

GUND Philbin classic teddy bear in full view ready for hugs.

GUND

GUND Philbin Classic Teddy Bear – 12-Inch Plush for Ages 1+ | Chocolate Brown

$22.18

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Melissa & Doug Food Groups watermelon for imaginative play and color recognition.

Melissa & Doug

Melissa & Doug Food Groups 21-Piece Wooden Play Food Set – Pretend Play Kitchen Toys

$22.85

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Melissa & Doug Shape Sorting Cube with 12 shapes promotes color and shape recognition during play.

Melissa & Doug

Melissa & Doug Shape Sorting Cube – Classic Wooden Toy with 12 Shapes

$23.40

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Intex Kiddie Pool Sunset Glow design for vibrant backyard fun on sunny days.

Intex

Intex Kiddie Pool Sunset Glow Design – 58 x 13 in Backyard Splash

$22.18

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

OOLY Rainy Dayz gel crayons in a vibrant tray for glass art.

Ooly

OOLY Rainy Dayz Gel Crayons – 12-Color Set for Glass & Paper

$23.47

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Hugeway basketball world cup bubble wand sparks active outdoor play

Hugeway

Hugeway Basketball World Cup Bubble Wand - Light-Up Bubble Machine for Kids

$15.32

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

CHEFAN farm animals felt board background for imaginative storytelling and classroom display.

CHEFAN

CHEFAN 99 Pcs Farm Animals Felt Story Board Set – 3.9 Ft Preschool Flannel Board

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

WQXWNFBA mini 3D printed animals with dragon eggs boost unboxing excitement.

WQXWNFBA

WQXWNFBA 25Pcs Mini 3D Printed Animals with Dragon Eggs Set – Fidget Toys Bulk

$18.06

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

The Kenkyo baby bouncer toy bar, assembled on a frame, enhances safe, engaging play for infants.

THE KENKYO

THE KENKYO Baby Bouncer Toy Bar – Safe, Compatible Sensory Attachment for Bliss & More

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Sunny Days Uno Pool Float with giant reverse card for eye-catching poolside lounging

Sunny Days Entertainment

Sunny Days Entertainment Uno Pool Float – 6' Giant Reverse Card Inflatable for Pool & Beach

$20.80

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Wild Republic beluga whale plush 15-inch: soft cuddle buddy for kids

WILD REPUBLIC

Wild Republic Beluga Whale Plush — 15-Inch Cuddlekins Toy for Kids

$20.15

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

POP Nancy Wheeler Stranger Things figure – 3.75-inch display-ready collectible for fans

POP

POP TV Nancy Wheeler (Stranger Things Season 5) Funko Vinyl Figure – 3.75-inch with Protector Box

$21.67

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

ToBeAce wind spinners reflect sunlight to deter birds in outdoor spaces

ToBeAce

ToBeAce Stainless Steel Bird Deterrents — Reflective 3D Wind Spinners for Outdoors

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Learning Resources Three Bear Family Storytime Picnic bears image invites imaginative play and language practice.

Learning Resources

Learning Resources Three Bear Family Storytime Picnic – Shape Sorter & Fine Motor Toy

$22.18

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

NJYW 8-in-1 fingerboard skate park kit, full set for creative play and dexterity.

NJYW

NJYW 8-in-1 Fingerboard Skate Park Kit – 2 Mini Fingerboards & DIY Ramp Set for Kids 5+

$23.13

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

FUN KIDZ Glow Slime 8 Colors Pack for vibrant creative play.

FUN KIDZ

FUN KIDZ Glow in the Dark Slime Kit – 8 Neon Colors, 1040 ml, for Kids 6+

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

QINGLER collapsible beach buckets ready for quick packing and sunny outings.

QINGLER

QINGLER Beach Sand Toys Set – 2-Pack Collapsible Buckets, Sifters, Shovels & Mesh Bag

$21.65

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Funko Tie-Dye Freddy plush front view with vibrant colors for display

Funko

Funko Pop! Plush: Five Nights at Freddy’s Tie-Dye Freddy — 9-Inch Collectible Plush

$23.81

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Hogaruly water balloon launcher in a backyard setup for active outdoor fun.

Hogaruly

Hogaruly Water Balloon Launcher Slingshots for Kids | 12 Reusable Balloons & Outdoor Summer Pool Toy

$15.32

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Klever Kits JOVA foil art dress-up kit inspires creative play with shimmering foil

Klever Kits

JOVA Klever Kits Foil Magnet Dress-Up Kit – 2-in-1 Kids Fashion DIY

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

MEHMEH Sleep with Jesus book cover with calming artwork for toddler bedtime.

MEHMEH

MEHMEH Sleep with Jesus: Bedtime Lullabies for Toddlers

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Stargarden wind spinners set, front view, enhancing outdoor decor with motion

Stargarden

Stargarden 4Pcs Metal Wind Spinners – Garden Pinwheels for Yard & Patio

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

CroBlissful flower-shaped bird feeder kit ready for painting and garden display.

CroBlissful

CroBlissful 12 Pack Bird Feeder Craft Kit – DIY Flower-Shape Feeders with Paint & Brushes

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Kinetic Sand Squish N’ Create set with blue, yellow and pink sand for creative tactile play.

Kinetic Sand

Kinetic Sand Squish N’ Create Playset – 13.5oz Blue, Yellow & Pink Sand with 5 Tools | Sensory Toys for Kids 3+

$24.77

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Liqilamii stress cube pink helps calm anxiety relief at home

Liqilamii

Liqilamii 4 Pack Stress Cube Fidget Toys – Large Slow-Rise Sensory Squishies for Relaxation

$18.06

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Leitee 6 Pcs DIY Wood Maracas in unfinished wood ready for customization.

Leitee

Leitee 6 Pcs DIY Wood Maracas – Unfinished Hand Painted Party Favors

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

QIMIALOL mahjong racks with pushers in a clear set for organized play.

QIMIALOL

QIMIALOL Mahjong Racks with Pushers – Clear All-in-One Set of 4 for Organized, Fast Play

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Goldge 3D Shark with articulated joints for tactile play and imaginative ocean exploration.

Goldge

Goldge 25PCS Ocean Animals — 3D Printed Articulated Fidget Toys with 25 Learning Cards

$20.80

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Mukorolee strawberry bunny plush 7in for soft cuddles and bedtime comfort

Mukorolee

Mukorolee 2PCS Plush Toy Pillow – Reversible Carrot & Strawberry Bunny Plush with Zipper

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Educational Insights Hot Dots pen close-up showing instant feedback during learning.

Educational Insights

Educational Insights Hot Dots: Let's Learn 1st Grade Reading – Interactive Workbook for Ages 6-7

$22.87

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

ROIISNM 51pcs 3D printed animals for an Easter basket display.

ROIISNM

ROIISNM 51PCS 3D Printed Animal Figurines Set with Jumbo 5.1in Egg & Twist-Lock Storage

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns