Free shipping on all U.S. orders · Tracked delivery FREE 30-DAY RETURNS · SECURE CHECKOUT · EMAIL SUPPORT

All products

Toy Gifts Under $25

Small gifts and stocking stuffers priced under $25: plush, fidgets, card games, craft kits, bath toys and mini building sets. Party supplies and replacement parts are left out so the page shows actual gifts, and only items currently in stock are listed. You'll find 1,488 toys from 898 brands, including Tonies, LEGO ...

Free shipping
Secure checkout
Free 30-day returns

EuroGraphics basketball spot-find puzzle box, compact packaging for easy gifting

EuroGraphics

EuroGraphics Basketball Spot & Find Puzzle – 100-Piece, Finished 13x19, Made in USA

$18.07

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Rubies Disco Jumpsuit front view with silver pattern, ideal for festive disco-themed events.

Rubies

Rubies Disco Jumpsuit Costume for Kids – Girl's Large (12-14) with Silver Disco Pattern

$20.65

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

JoyCat unicorn sticker book cover—durable, reusable play for toddlers.

JoyCat

JoyCat Reusable Sticker Book Set (3-Pack): Unicorn, Fairies & Mermaid – 90 Pcs for Toddlers

$23.81

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Sumobaby Seahorse musical toy front view, engaging senses during play

Sumobaby

Sumobaby 5-in-1 Musical Seahorse Plush Toy – Tummy Time, 0-12 Months

$22.58

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Sumobaby Seahorse musical toy front view stimulates visual tracking with soft textures.

Sumobaby

Sumobaby Seahorse Musical Toy — 5-in-1 Sensory Plush for 0-12 Months

$22.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

ESSENSON Magic Clay 84 colors swatches for vibrant, mixable shades in kids’ crafts.

ESSENSON

ESSENSON Magic Clay: 84-Color Air Dry Modeling Clay for Kids

$22.56

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

KUCCO-PILLOW 11-inch basketball plush for cozy hugs and room decor

KUCCO-PILLOW

KUCCO-PILLOW Funny Basketball Plush — 11-Inch Cute Throw Pillow & Plush Toy

$23.73

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

GAMENOTE magnetic number tracing board front view for early numeracy practice

GAMENOTE

GAMENOTE Magnetic Number Tracing Board – 2-in-1 Double-Sided Numbers 1-20 for Toddlers & Kids

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Jetbotell giraffe pull back vehicle supports motor skills and color recognition

Jetbotell

Jetbotell Pull Back Vehicle Set — Soft Animal Cars for Toddlers 1-3

$24.88

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Play-Doh Kawaii Cloud scented slime with mint chocolate chip for fluffy sensory play

Play-Doh

Play-Doh Kawaii Mix & Play Scented Slime 6-Pack – Cloud, Butter, Foam, Stretch

$22.39

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Gigilli light-up whale bath toy sprinkles water for engaging bath play.

Gigilli

Gigilli Baby Bath Toys: Light-Up Whale Sprinkler for Toddlers 1-3 | Rechargeable Bath Time Fun

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Thomas & Friends Thomas push-along engine boosts fine motor skills during imaginative play.

THOMAS & FRIENDS

Thomas & Friends Construction Crew Diecast Vehicle Set — 5 Push-Along Trains for Preschool (Ages 3+)

$24.11

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

ZURU Smashers Dino Island Egg Series 5 in a PDQ display for easy shopping.

ZURU

ZURU Smashers Dino Island Egg – Series 5 Mini Dino Surprise (PDQ)

$24.09

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Newtay microphone candy tubes in purple add vibrant party decor and visual flair.

Newtay

Newtay 12 Pcs Microphone Candy Tubes and Covers — Kpop Themed Karaoke Party Props

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

ShinyRelief pink daisy pool float—4-pack, perfect for festive pool parties.

ShinyRelief

ShinyRelief 4-Pcs Pink Daisy Pool Floats - 19.7-Inch Inflatable Flowers

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

HOTPLACY mandala wind chime kit pieces ready for color-filled creativity and crafts

HOTPLACY

HOTPLACY 24-Set Mandala Wind Chime Craft Kit for Kids | DIY Color Your Own Mandala Windchimes

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Impossmaker dragon egg assembly shows vibrant colors for Easter fun.

Impossmaker

Impossmaker 12pcs 3D Printed Dragon Eggs – Prefilled Easter Eggs for Kids

$21.41

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Elitevia toddler sand water table with electric pump for interactive play.

Elitevia

Elitevia Upgraded Toddler Sand & Water Table with Electric Pump – 4-in-1 Kitchen Play Sink for Ages 3+ (Pink)

$15.32

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Teekdeer Montessori Busy Book with felt activities boosts toddler fine motor skills.

Teekdeer

Teekdeer Montessori Busy Book for Toddlers 1-3 | Sensory & Color Sorting Educational Toy

$24.77

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

RURING dragon egg 3D printed with movable joints for imaginative play

RURING

RURING 12Pcs 3D Printed Dragon Eggs – Prefilled Easter Eggs & Dragon Fidget Toys

$22.58

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Masters of the Universe Lion-O Origins figure front view for dynamic display and posing.

Masters of the Universe

Masters of the Universe Origins Lion-O – 5.5-Inch Crossover Figure with Armor & Sword of Omens

$24.35

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Fuggler Powerpuff Buttercup 9-inch plush close-up; soft texture for hugs.

Fuggler

Fuggler Powerpuff Buttercup 9-Inch Plush by ZURU – Funny Ugly Monster Toy, Collectible Plush for Fans

$19.43

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Mr.Klay air dry clay kit with twenty jars encourages fine motor skills during sculpting

Mr.Klay

Mr.Klay Air Dry Modeling Clay for Kids – Dinosaurs DIY Art Kit with Tools & Scene Board

$17.24

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Science Can robot speaker assembly with laser-cut wooden puzzles for hands-on STEM

Science Can

Science Can DIY Bluetooth Speaker Kit with Rotating Head Robot — STEM Toys 8-13

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Impossmaker 8in Easter dragon egg with dragon inside, vivid texture for collectible display

Impossmaker

Impossmaker 8-In Easter Dragon Eggs with Inside Dragon | Articulated Crystal Dragon Fidget Toy

$21.35

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

OFNMY Shrinky Dink sheets kit ready for colorful prints and keychain projects.

OFNMY

OFNMY 225PCS Printable Shrinky Dink Sheets Kit — Inkjet Printable Shrink Plastic for Keychains & DIY Crafts

$20.40

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

The Storybook Kids Explorers Club watering can for little gardeners with safe, easy-grip design

THE STORYBOOK KIDS EXPLORERS CLUB

Kids Gardening Set for Toddlers | Watering Can, Trowel, Rake, Shovel, Gloves & Tote Bag | The Storybook Kids Explorers Club

$20.80

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

HyBaiS 24-inch dragon glow-in-the-dark figure for dramatic display and night-time mood lighting.

HyBaiS

HyBaiS 24-Inch Glow-in-the-Dark 3D Printed Dragon — Large Poseable Figurine

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

ROHSCE bath toy soccer ball promotes active tub play and ball recognition.

ROHSCE

ROHSCE Bath Toys: Soft Hole-Free Montessori Sensory Balls for Babies & Toddlers

$18.06

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

YUETIANE spider web shooters gloves for kids, comfortable grip during play.

YUETIANE

YUETIANE Spider Web Shooters Set – 2 Kids Wrist Launchers, Gloves & Darts | Party Favors

$23.81

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Adena Montessori spinning rainbow drum close-up showing color patterns for early visual tracking.

Adena Montessori

Adena Montessori Baby Toys Play Kit – Spinning Rainbow Drum, Mirror Peekaboo Puzzle & Rainbow Fabric Ball for 6-12 Months

$22.37

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

MinFyberd floating Mahjong table in a pink-accent pool setting.

MinFyberd

MinFyberd 32x32 Inch Floating Mahjong Table for Pool & Hot Tub - Pink

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Blokees Jurassic World Surprise Egg 01 with collectible dinosaur figures for display and imaginative play.

BLOKEES

BLOKEES Jurassic World Surprise Egg 01 – 12 in 1 Display

$17.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Glowpoint Splash Pad arch sprinkler for cooling fun.

GLOWPOINT

Glowpoint Splash Pad – Large 75-Inch Outdoor Water Play Mat for Kids & Dogs

$18.06

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Franklin Sports foam baseballs 3-pack in packaging, ready for at-home practice.

Franklin Sports

Franklin Sports Foam Baseballs – Soft Practice Balls for Kids | 3 Pack | MLB Licensed

$18.06

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

YUSSBCU video walkie talkies front view enabling real time play coordination indoors.

YUSSBCU

YUSSBCU Upgraded Video Walkie Talkies for Kids – 2 Pack Rechargeable (Pink/Blue) with Real-Time Video & Voice

$22.15

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

eeBoo Lion in My Way game box front, inviting cooperative imagination for family play

eeBoo

eeBoo Lion in My Way Game – Cooperative Imaginative Play for 2-4 Players, Ages 5+

$22.72

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Glowpoint 87-inch splash pad in a large round layout for family backyard water play

GLOWPOINT

Glowpoint 87” Large Non-Slip Splash Pad – Round Outdoor Water Sprinkler for Kids & Dogs

$19.43

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

XINNOVEL Bubble Machine on a stand with adjustable height for versatile toddler play.

XINNOVEL

XINNOVEL Bubble Machine for Toddlers 3-5 | Lights, Music & Remote

$19.43

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Ploomi 2026 pink 4-in-1 table front view for sand and water play.

Ploomi

Ploomi 2026 Upgraded 4-in-1 Sand & Water Table – Pink for Toddlers to Kids (Ages 18m-8y)

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns