Pick Your Poison party game box ready for White Elephant and family game night.
Close-up of Pick Your Poison scenario cards offering 300 prompts for endless laughs.
Players engage in Pick Your Poison tabletop play during a lively session.
Group reveals picks in a tense Pick Your Poison moment at the table.
Friends and family enjoy Pick Your Poison, sparking playful conversation and bold choices.
After Dark Edition box ready to add bold twists to Pick Your Poison.
Compact Pick Your Poison packaging makes a great stocking stuffer or gift.
Ages 10+ group gathers for 30–60 minute Pick Your Poison play.

Pick Your Poison

Pick Your Poison Party Game – What Would You Rather Do? Family Card Game for White Elephant & Gift Exchanges

High-performance toys made for confident daily results

$34.50

3 shoppers currently have this item in cart.

Low stock: only 5 left in inventory. Add to cart before it's gone.

Shop Pay installment options may appear at checkout where eligible.

Free shipping Secure checkout 100% refund eligible
Bundle & save Buy 2 and save checkout time

Premium toys quality selected for United States (USA) customers.

Routine pack Build your routine pack (3)

Fast dispatch with always-free shipping and secure checkout on every order.

Free shipping

i

Free shipping on every order. Fast dispatch, tracked delivery, and secure checkout included.

Easy returns

i

Simple return flow and responsive support for eligible items.

Peak-demand shipping delays

i

During high demand, deliveries may experience short carrier delays. Tracking updates remain active for every order.

24/7 customer support

Questions before checkout? Our team is available and ready to help.

Return & RefundEasy returns and policy details Shipping PolicyDelivery process and tracking info
Share

Why customers choose ToyTerrax Toys and Games

Turn any gathering into a playful challenge

Pick Your Poison is a lively family-friendly party game that invites everyone to weigh outrageous options. By combining two Poison cards, players craft a bold "What would you rather do?" scenario. With three or more players, tension builds as choices are revealed and everyone weighs whose pick is the bravest, wittiest, or most surprising.

What makes it endlessly entertaining

  • 300 Scenario Cards: a vast library of prompts fuels countless laughs and fresh pairings across game nights.
  • Anonymous Picks: players cast votes secretly, which adds suspense and anticipation to every round.
  • Reveal & React: after the reveal, conversations ignite as friends compare choices and celebrate bold takes.
  • Flexible Playtime: designed for 30–60 minutes, making it suitable for quick sessions or longer game nights.

Perfect for celebrations and gift exchanges

  • White Elephant & Secret Santa: a playful twist that pairs well with gift swaps and party games.
  • Stocking Stuffers & Holiday Gifts: compact packaging makes it a thoughtful and easy-to-wrap present.
  • Ages 10+: welcomes family members and friends to join in the fun, regardless of age variation.
  • 3–10 Players: versatile enough to scale for small gatherings or larger groups.

Notes on variety and added fun

Looking for more twists? Try pairing Pick Your Poison with the After Dark Edition for bolder prompts and different vibes. The core idea remains the same: explore possibilities, share moments, and enjoy the playful tension of choosing together—with no guarantees, just the fun of the moment.

FAQ

Q: What is Pick Your Poison Party Game?

A: A playful card game where players mix two prompts to create a bold scenario and vote anonymously.

Q: Who is it for and how long does it take?

A: For 3–10 players, ages 10+, with play sessions typically lasting 30–60 minutes.

You may also like