Pick Your Poison front cover invites players to dive into playful risk
The card pile sparks curiosity and quick, funny decisions
A player selecting prompts fuels outrageous conversations and laughter
Family Expansion Pack brings fresh prompts for bigger groups
400 scenario cards offer thousands of humorous matchups
Ideal for game nights and lively gatherings
A fun holiday gift that sparks conversation
Compact box fits shelves and travels for play on the go

Pick Your Poison

Pick Your Poison Party Game + Family Expansion Set | What Would You Rather Do?

High-performance toys made for confident daily results

$42.66

3 shoppers currently have this item in cart.

Low stock: only 5 left in inventory. Add to cart before it's gone.

Shop Pay installment options may appear at checkout where eligible.

Free shipping Secure checkout 100% refund eligible
Bundle & save Buy 2 and save checkout time

Premium toys quality selected for United States (USA) customers.

Routine pack Build your routine pack (3)

Fast dispatch with always-free shipping and secure checkout on every order.

Free shipping

i

Free shipping on every order. Fast dispatch, tracked delivery, and secure checkout included.

Easy returns

i

Simple return flow and responsive support for eligible items.

Peak-demand shipping delays

i

During high demand, deliveries may experience short carrier delays. Tracking updates remain active for every order.

24/7 customer support

Questions before checkout? Our team is available and ready to help.

Return & RefundEasy returns and policy details Shipping PolicyDelivery process and tracking info
Share

Why customers choose ToyTerrax Toys and Games

Endless laughs with 400 scenarios

When friends gather, Pick Your Poison invites bold choices and playful debates. The prompts spark curiosity, mix cheeky boldness with lighthearted fun, and keep energy high without pressure. This set blends a base game with a Family Expansion Pack to unlock thousands of possible pairings, so nights stay fresh and memorable rather than repetitive.

Designed for a wide range of players, the experience centers on quick decisions, relatable situations, and real-time reactions. It thrives on shared reactions, inside jokes, and the stories that emerge after each round. The tone stays friendly and approachable, offering entertainment that feels inclusive and easy to pick up.

What’s included

  • 400 Scenario Cards that mix and match for endless combinations
  • Base game plus Family Expansion Pack for extended fun
  • Ages 10+; Players 3–10; Session length 30–60 minutes

How to play in real life

Two Poison cards are drawn and combined to form a lighthearted dilemma. Players weigh options, make quick choices, and react to one another’s picks, sparking conversations and shared laughter.

For more variety, you can pair the game with the After Dark Edition Set to add additional prompts and energy for larger groups or late-night gaming sessions.

Setup, vibe, and accessibility

Setup is fast—shuffle, deal two Poison cards, and you’re ready to play. The prompts are designed for mixed-age groups, balancing cheeky humor with broad appeal so everyone can join in confidently.

Perfect for occasions

  • Thanksgiving, Friendsgiving, and other holiday gatherings
  • White Elephant, Secret Santa, and gift exchanges
  • Stocking stuffers and casual game nights with friends

Why people reach for Pick Your Poison

The game blends straightforward rules with high replay value. It’s compact for travel, encourages conversation, and helps reveal playful sides of your group without pressure or guarantees, just possibilities for a fun evening.

FAQ

Q: What ages and how many players is this game designed for?

A: Ages 10+, supports 3–10 players, with 30–60 minute sessions.

Q: What does this set include and can I expand it further?

A: Includes base game plus Family Expansion with 400 cards; compatible with the After Dark Edition for more prompts.

You may also like