Free shipping on all U.S. orders · Tracked delivery FREE 30-DAY RETURNS · SECURE CHECKOUT · EMAIL SUPPORT

All products

Toy Gifts Under $25

Small gifts and stocking stuffers priced under $25: plush, fidgets, card games, craft kits, bath toys and mini building sets. Party supplies and replacement parts are left out so the page shows actual gifts, and only items currently in stock are listed. You'll find 1,488 toys from 898 brands, including Tonies, LEGO ...

Free shipping
Secure checkout
Free 30-day returns

Klever Kits gem painting unicorn—sparkling design with no glue needed.

Klever Kits

Klever Kits 16 Projects Gem Painting Kit for Kids – 5D Diamond Art & 5 Crafts, Ages 6-12

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Wettarn emotional luminous stone stress ball glows after sunlight exposure for calming moments

Wettarn

Wettarn 30 Sets Emotional Luminous Stone Stress Ball Gift Set – Positive Cards for Coworkers, Teachers & Nurses

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Tavaleu pool floats 2-pack saddle for versatile pool seating and lounging.

Tavaleu

Tavaleu Pool Floats - 2 Pack Inflatable Loungers for Adults | 4-in-1 Pool Float Lounger

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Bandai Namco Itachi Uchiha 5in figure front view for display

Bandai Namco

Ultimate Legends Naruto Itachi Uchiha 5-Inch Action Figure | Bandai Namco

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

JOYIN baseball fidget spinner pack for kids, perfect party favors.

JOYIN

JOYIN 72-Count Baseball Fidget Spinners for Kids | Party Favors & Classroom Toys

$21.35

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Tonies Bedtime Songs character front view illustrating a calming bedtime companion.

Tonies

Tonies Bedtime Songs Audio Play Character – 27 Calming Tracks for 3+

$24.84

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

GUND Cozys Lion plush 10-inch size for cozy family hugs.

GUND

GUND Cozys Collection Lion Plush – 10-Inch Cuddly Friend for All Ages

$18.47

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

SSAWER magnetic blocks forest scene with knight and princess supports imaginative play and fine motor skills.

SSAWER

SSAWER Magnetic Blocks 100-Piece Set | STEM Tiles for Creative Building – Forest & Lava Worlds (Ages 3+)

$18.88

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Squishmallows Snoopy & Woodstock BBQ Americana 8in full plush for cozy travel cuddles

Squishmallows

Squishmallows Original Peanuts 8in Snoopy & Woodstock BBQ Americana – Official Jazwares Plush

$17.26

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

YONHAN Lumi Board 16-inch box view, ideal for gifting and quick setup.

YONHAN

YONHAN 16-Inch LED Drawing Board for Kids – Rechargeable, Portable Doodle Glow with 7 Colors

$18.06

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Imagimake Mirror Mosaic princess stickers add radiant sparkle to kids' crafts.

Imagimake

Imagimake Mirror Mosaic Princess & Unicorn Kids Art Set | DIY Craft Kit for Girls Ages 4-8 | Travel-Friendly

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Colorations tempera paint orange 1 gal packshot highlights vibrant classroom-ready color

Colorations

Colorations Paraben-Free Tempera Paint – 1 Gallon Orange | Non-Toxic, Made in USA, Classroom Bulk

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Ssqauvig cat paw ice cube design visual for mood enhancement and stress relief

Ssqauvig

Ssqauvig Cat Paw Ice Cube Squishy – 1.98-Inch Soft Squeeze Fidget Toy

$12.58

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Nano-MALS Pawtricia blue kitty hands and ears—interactive pet play and fidget fun.

NANO-MALS

Nano-MALS Pawtricia Blue Kitty – Interactive Electronic Pet & Fidget Toy

$19.43

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

GobiDex magnetic blocks packaging featuring a ready-to-gift STEM toy for imaginative play.

GobiDex

GobiDex 100-Piece Magnetic Blocks for Kids 3+ | MagWonder STEM Building Toys

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Klever Kits Princess Foil Art Kit showing full contents for imaginative play.

Klever Kits

Klever Kits Princess Foil Art Kit for Kids - Mess-Free Craft, Travel-Friendly

$18.50

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Superlong 12-disc stainless steel wind spinner gleams in sunlight to deter birds.

Superlong

Superlong 12-Disc Stainless Steel 3D Wind Spinners Bird Deterrents – Outdoor Garden Decor

$18.74

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Superlong Bird Deterrents: 12-disc 3D wind spinners deter birds while adding motion

Superlong

Superlong Bird Deterrents – 12-Disc 3D Wind Spinners for Outdoors

$18.06

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Superlong 3D wind spinner outdoor disc in sunlight deters birds

Superlong

Superlong 12-Disc Stainless Steel 3D Wind Spinners Bird Deterrents for Outdoor Spaces

$21.48

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Monster Jam Mini Jams Dragon truck speeds toward the skull escape obstacle for jungle action.

Monster Jam

Monster Jam Mini Jams Skull Escape Playset – 2 Exclusive Dragons & El Toro Loco Trucks

$19.29

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Wettarn emotional luminous cactus ball green for quick desk stress relief.

Wettarn

Wettarn 30-Set Emotional Luminous Cactus Stress Ball Gift Bundle – Glow, Cards & Bags for Graduation & Appreciation

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Ycixri Animal Crossing New Leaf plush, front view, soft fabric ideal for cozy playtime

Ycixri

Ycixri Animal Crossing New Leaf Plush Toy – 8-Inch Collectible Stuffed Doll

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Great Dachong musical crawling dog toy engaging babies with music and movement

great dachong

Great Dachong Musical Crawling Dog Toy for Babies 6-12 Months – Dancing Lights & Recording

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Melissa & Doug Created by Me Sparkle & Shimmer beads in wooden box for organization.

Melissa & Doug

Melissa & Doug Created by Me! Sparkle & Shimmer Beads – 340+ Wooden Beads Jewelry Kit

$24.50

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

JOYIN 48-pcs cone chalks set in vibrant colors for outdoor art play

JOYIN

JOYIN 48 Pcs Cone Chalk Set – Washable, Non-Toxic Jumbo Sidewalk Chalks in 12 Colors

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Lincia 600-sheet macaron paper chain strips for quick colorful banners

Lincia

Lincia 600 Sheet Paper Chain Garland Strips – 1x8 in DIY Decorations with Tape (Macaron)

$20.80

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Adena Montessori wooden 12-shape puzzle board for toddlers, boosts early shape recognition and motor skills.

Adena Montessori

Adena Montessori Wooden Puzzles for Toddlers – 12-Piece Shape Peg Board with Knobs

$24.99

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

CUUGO LET'S GO! CG foam pogo stick base offers stable, safe outdoor play for kids.

CUUGO LET'S GO! CG

CUUGO LET'S GO! CG Foam Pogo Stick – Kids Outdoor Toy, Safe Non-Slip Pedal, Pink

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Buffalo Games Junior Detective case clues in action, boosting investigation skills during family game night.

Buffalo Games

Buffalo Games Junior Detective Game – Cooperative Mystery for Kids 6-10

$23.74

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

CUUGO LET'S GO CG foam pogo jumper side view highlighting active play and balance

CUUGO LET'S GO! CG

CUUGO LET'S GO CG Foam Pogo Jumper for Kids 3-12 – Indoor/Outdoor Toy (Green Blue)

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Smirodi reusable water balloons 6-pack for summer pool play

Smirodi

Smirodi 6 Pcs Reusable Magnetic Water Balloons – Outdoor Pool & Beach Fun

$22.58

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Bluey Fuzzies Deluxe Figure Pack front view for display and collection.

Bluey

Bluey Fuzzies Deluxe Figure Pack — 8 Collectible Mini-Figures, Trading Card & Collector's Guide

$21.48

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

One Piece Luffy 6in action figure in a dynamic pose for display and play.

One Piece

One Piece Monkey D. Luffy 6″ Action Figure – 22 Points of Articulation, 6 Accessories

$21.62

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

LYDTICK 30-pack rainbow beach balls ready for bulk parties and summer games.

LYDTICK

LYDTICK 30 Pack Rainbow Beach Balls – 12" Inflatable Pool Toys for Summer Water Games

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Toyland Paw Patrol bubbles with dual-hole wand for varied bubble sizes outdoors.

Toyland

Toyland Pack of 12 Paw Patrol Bubbles with Wands – 2 fl oz & Maze Lid

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Galison Capeside Victorian foil puzzle reveals ornate manor and blooming garden, ideal for relaxing evenings.

Galison

Galison Capeside Victorian 1000-Piece Foil Jigsaw Puzzle by Joy Laforme

$20.74

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

4E's Novelty 12-box chalk pack front view for colorful party favors.

4E's Novelty

4E's Novelty 12 Boxes Sidewalk Chalk – Jumbo Non-Toxic Party Favors for Kids

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Superlong 3D wind spinner disc reflects sunlight to deter birds from patio.

Superlong

Superlong 3D Wind Spinner Bird Deterrents — 12 Stainless Discs, 4 Sets for Patio & Garden

$18.74

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Jax Sequence in a Tin game board shown for strategic play and family gathering.

Jax

Sequence in a Tin by Jax — Five-in-a-Row Strategy Game for 2–12 Players

$23.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Winemana reflective pinwheel shimmer in sun to gently deter birds from the garden

winemana

Winemana 12-Pack Reflective Pinwheels for Garden Bird Deterrence (Green)

$15.32

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

‹ 1 … 21 22 23 24 25 … 38 ›