Free shipping on all U.S. orders · Tracked delivery FREE 30-DAY RETURNS · SECURE CHECKOUT · EMAIL SUPPORT

All products

Toy Gifts Under $25

Small gifts and stocking stuffers priced under $25: plush, fidgets, card games, craft kits, bath toys and mini building sets. Party supplies and replacement parts are left out so the page shows actual gifts, and only items currently in stock are listed. You'll find 1,488 toys from 898 brands, including Tonies, LEGO ...

Free shipping
Secure checkout
Free 30-day returns

Moose 5 Love Languages Card Game prompt cards spark thoughtful conversations.

Moose

Moose The 5 Love Languages Card Game – 300 Prompts for Deeper Connection

$24.65

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

4E's Novelty octopus water balls pack of 6 for kids' bath time and splashy play

4E's Novelty

4E's Novelty Octopus Water Balls – Pack of 6 Pool Toys for Kids | Bath, Pool & Beach Fun

$20.80

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

WDYQJE retro gaming console front view in bright yellow for on-the-go fun.

WDYQJE

WDYQJE Retro Gaming Console – 400 Classic Games, 3.0-inch IPS Screen, 1020mAh Battery, Portable Yellow Handheld

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

BOKUFLY Jesus Plush Doll in red robe, front view, comforting display.

BOKUFLY

BOKUFLY Jesus Plush Doll 14.2in Red Robe – Soft Embroidered Plush

$23.87

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

HopeRock hover ball with soft foam bumper for safe indoor play.

HopeRock

HopeRock Hover Soccer Ball Toys for Kids – Indoor & Outdoor LED Fun

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

BOKUFLY Jesus plush doll with detailed face embroidery for lifelike charm.

BOKUFLY

BOKUFLY Jesus Plush Doll 14.2in – Soft Christian Plush Toy for Easter

$23.87

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

DIYDEC stress cubes in vibrant colors held in hand for stress relief.

DIYDEC

DIYDEC 24 Pcs Stress Cube Toys – 8 Color Slow Rising Squeeze Fidget Balls for Kids & Classrooms

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

JOYIN 4 Pcs fidget fruit pineapple toy, flexible and fun for stress relief.

JOYIN

JOYIN 4 Pcs 3D Printed Fidget Fruit Toys – Flexible Desk Fidgets for Stress Relief

$12.58

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

ZRW Capybara Squishy Glitter capybara design with shimmering detail for desk decor

ZRW

ZRW Capybara Squishy Glitter | Soft Fidget for Desk Decor & Stress Relief

$18.04

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Super Wings Jett transformable toy jet airplane ready for imaginative play and exploration

Super Wings

Super Wings Transformable Toys: Jett Airplane 2-in-1 Rescue Bots for Kids Aged 3-7

$24.30

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

JOYIN green ankle skip ball with flashing lights for vibrant indoor and outdoor play.

JOYIN

JOYIN Green Ankle Skip Ball with Flashing Lights – Indoor & Outdoor Fun for Kids 3+

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

XPQKDC big soft sensory stress ball blue texture for calming pressure relief.

XPQKDC

XPQKDC 3Pc Big Soft Sensory Stress Balls – Large Textured Memory Gel Fidget Toys

$15.30

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

PkghoKids T13 front view for compact desk display and collection.

PkghoKids

PkghoKids 8-Inch T13 Action Figure Set – Assembly Complete, Fully Articulated Nova T-13 for Desktop Display

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Tozuoup Busy Board LED switches for fine motor skill development

Tozuoup

Tozuoup Busy Board Montessori Toys for Toddlers – Sensory Activity & Fine Motor Learning (Ages 1–4)

$22.58

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Golinkid Magic Water Elf Toy Kit bottle setup with sparkling gel colors for creative play.

Golinkid

Golinkid Magic Water Elf Toy Kit — 12 Bottles, 18 Molds, 70ml Aqua Fairy Gel for Kids

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Hagusahuo Black Cat Plush 8-inch for cozy bedtime cuddles.

Hagusahuo

Hagusahuo Black Cat Plush - 8-Inch Donut Headpiece Kawaii Kitty Stuffed Animal

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Dreamon Farm Sand Toy Animal Molds for shaping playful wildlife in sand.

Dreamon

Dreamon Beach Toys for Kids – 29-Piece Farm Sand Kit with Collapsible Buckets

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Funko Games Five Nights Night Frights game box with display window, ideal for display and gifting

FUNKO GAMES

Funko Games Five Nights at Freddy's Night of Frights! Board Game — 2-4 Players, Ages 8+

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

AOWEC Duck Quacking Keychain front view showing sound and LED lights

AOWEC

AOWEC Duck Quacking Fidget Toy – USB Rechargeable Duck Keychain with Sound & LED

$19.43

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

ColoPlay Taba Squishy Kit contents for large, complex squishy projects.

ColoPlay

ColoPlay Taba Squishy Kit – 32oz Silicone, Bubble-Free & Fast Cure (2-3h) with Guided Manual

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Elmer’s Neon Sky Slime Kit blue glue for vibrant color slime crafting at home

Elmer's

Elmer’s Neon Sky Slime Kit – 4-Piece Slime Set with Blue & Pink Glue and Activators

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Tngan nesting dolls dog figure—playful stacking toy for imaginative play and early learning.

Tngan

Tngan Nesting Dolls, 5Pcs 6" Tall Handmade Russian Matryoshka for Kids – Wooden Stacking Toys

$20.80

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

BURIESUR 34-piece dinosaur toy set with storage box for easy cleanup.

BURIESUR

BURIESUR 34-Piece Dinosaur Toys for Kids 3-5 with Storage Box – Realistic Dino Figures

$22.43

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Foaincore 2026 gown fabric close-up showing wrinkle resistance for easy wear.

Foaincore

Foaincore 2026 Year Preschool Graduation Gown Cap Tassel Set with Printed Stole – Red, Size 30

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Tonies Spirit Untamed Spirit figurine for imaginative play and storytelling adventures

Tonies

Tonies Spirit Untamed Audio Toy Figurine – 75-Min Story on Toniebox

$18.06

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

NIUBEHOHO graduation axolotl plush with cap for kindergartners' celebrations and cuddles

NIUBEHOHO

NIUBEHOHO Graduation Axolotl Plush with Cap, 10 Inch Pink Diploma Toy

$13.95

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

JOYSINTOY Tic-Tac-Toe board inflates for instant pool play.

JOYSINTOY

JOYSINTOY Inflatable Tic-Tac-Toe Pool Game Set – 57 x 55 in, 10 Balls, Quick Pump

$15.32

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

PkghoKids T13 fully articulated figure in blue noctilucent for dynamic posing.

PkghoKids

PkghoKids T13 Fully Articulated 7.2-Inch Pre-Assembled Action Figure (Blue Noctilucent) - Desktop Decor & Collectors Toy

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Funko Pop! Plush Tie-Dye Foxy figure in vibrant colors for display.

Funko

Funko Pop! Plush: Five Nights at Freddy's Tie-Dye Foxy – 7-Inch Collectible Plush | Funko

$23.65

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Oink Games Scout card play shows fast, tense hand management for quick family rounds.

Oink Games

Oink Games Scout — Award-Nominated Strategic Hand Management for 2-5 Players (20-Minute Travel Family Game)

$22.14

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Doxrmuru cowgirl costume set for kids, ideal for dress-up play.

Doxrmuru

Doxrmuru Cowgirl Costume for Girls 7-8 Years – Western Rodeo Dress Up Outfit

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

OUOZZZ 12.6-inch soft baby doll with cozy fabric for safe teething-friendly play

OUOZZZ

OUOZZZ 12.6-inch Soft Baby Doll Toy for 1+ Year Old Girls – Easter Bunny Plush Gift

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Hunfur dancing cactus toy front view with bright lights and music.

Hunfur

Hunfur Interactive Dancing Cactus Toy – Recording, Singing, LED Lights, 4-Volume for Baby and Toddler (6-36 Months)

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Sloosh 12-pcs sand buckets set in bright colors for kids' beach fun

Sloosh

Sloosh 12-Pcs Sand Buckets & Shovels Set for Kids – Colorful Beach Pails with Handles (24 Pieces)

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Kryzomat 100-piece magnetic castle blocks for imaginative castle-building play

Kryzomat

Kryzomat 100Pcs Magnetic Blocks – Pink Princess Castle Toy for Kids 3+

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

WMXDU mini magnetic blocks in iron box contents for portable play and travel

WMXDU

WMXDU Mini Magnetic Blocks – 49-Piece Magnetic Cubes with Iron Box | STEM Toy for 3+

$17.39

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Raxurt dog splash pad with anti-slip surface for safe outdoor play.

Raxurt

Raxurt Dog Water Toys | 59in Anti-Slip Splash Pad – 0.55mm Thick, Durable, BPA-Free Backyard Fountain

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Imagimake Window Art Princess suncatcher kit brightens windows and inspires creative kids

Imagimake

Imagimake Window Art Princess Suncatcher Kit | DIY Glass Painting for Kids 6–12

$24.88

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Imagimake window art rocket suncatcher brightens windows with colorful design for kids.

Imagimake

Imagimake Window Art for Kids - Rocket Suncatcher Kit (Ages 5-12)

$24.88

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

TOSY Magnet Cube 2x2 with eight blocks for smooth rotation and versatile configurations.

TOSY

TOSY Magnet Cube 2x2: 2x2x2 Puzzle Cube & Customizable Infinity Cube (Glow with UV Light) – 2-Pack Gift

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

‹ 1 … 15 16 17 18 19 … 38 ›