Free shipping on all U.S. orders · Tracked delivery FREE 30-DAY RETURNS · SECURE CHECKOUT · EMAIL SUPPORT

All products

Toy Gifts Under $25

Small gifts and stocking stuffers priced under $25: plush, fidgets, card games, craft kits, bath toys and mini building sets. Party supplies and replacement parts are left out so the page shows actual gifts, and only items currently in stock are listed. You'll find 1,488 toys from 898 brands, including Tonies, LEGO ...

Free shipping
Secure checkout
Free 30-day returns

AGENTLAN Magic Puff Kit unicorn design transforms kids' drawings into playful 3D art.

AGENTLAN

AGENTLAN Magic Puff Kit for Kids – 3D Puff Art with Unicorn & Princess

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Weysat 7-inch desk goose Valentines outfit, adds festive charm to your desk decor.

Weysat

Weysat 10-Pack 7-Inch Desk Goose Outfits with Hair Bows – Holiday Dress Sets for Mini Goose Figurines

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

McFarlane Toys TMNT Michelangelo Page Punchers figure front view for display and poseability

McFarlane Toys

McFarlane Toys TMNT Michelangelo 5-Inch Page Punchers Figure with Exclusive Comic

$20.81

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

McFarlane Toys Raphael Page Punchers figure front view with ultra-poseable articulation.

McFarlane Toys

McFarlane Toys Raphael Page Punchers 5-Inch Action Figure with Exclusive IDW Comic

$20.81

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Funko Scooby-Doo sandwich collectible vinyl figure for display and collection

Funko

Funko Pop! Scooby-Doo with Sandwich – Collectible Vinyl Figure | Official Merchandise

$24.00

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Jreiiolk Sticky Rolls Kit packaging shows a colorful, ready-to-gift craft set for kids.

Jreiiolk

Jreiiolk Sticky Rolls Craft Kit — 400+ Reusable Mini Stickers, 8 Sticker Rolls, 6 Bracelets + 4 Necklaces, 60-Page Book (Pink)

$20.78

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Bits and Pieces bunnies puzzle box featuring two designs for relaxing, engaging evenings

Bits and Pieces

Bits and Pieces – Two 300-Piece Jigsaw Puzzles by Jane Maday: Bunnies & Mice, 18 x 24 Inches Completed

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Seenelling Class of 2026 graduation ball with glitter for standout party decor and photos.

Seenelling

Seenelling 8 Pcs 2026 Graduation Beach Balls – 13\" Inflatable Set

$16.69

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Play-Doh Dino Tools Stegosaurus cutter shapes fun textures for budding artists

Play-Doh

Play-Doh Dino Tools - 5 Dinosaur-Themed Modeling Tools for Creative Play

$24.37

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

KASAK Falling Game sticks in action during basketball drop improving hand-eye coordination

KASAK

KASAK Falling Game – Quick Reflex & Hand-Eye Training for All Ages | Portable

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

3 Otters wind-up chick yellow closeup showing soft plush texture for Easter fun

3 otters

3 Otters 12pc Wind-Up Chickens Plush Toys — Easter Party Favors

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

POP Funko Eleven Bandana figure in bundle packaging with protective display

POP

POP Funko TV: Eleven with Bandana (Season 5) – 3.75in Vinyl Figure + Box Protector

$22.66

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Aruemp 7-in-1 Montessori shape sorter boosts early problem-solving during playtime

aruemp

aruemp 7-in-1 Montessori Baby Toys — Shape Sorter, Sensory Bin, Stacking Cups

$24.22

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Learning Resources Number Turtles momma and baby shells for color matching and counting play

Learning Resources

Learning Resources Number Turtles Set – 15 Pieces for Fine Motor & Early Math

$24.78

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Monster Jam Megalodon truck 1:64 with authentic chassis for realistic play

Monster Jam

Monster Jam Official Megalodon 1:64 Monster Truck & Dirt Bike 2-Pack

$19.43

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Wiggance 58-piece articulated animals set for desk display and collection.

wiggance

Wiggance 58-Piece 3D Printed Animals – Articulated Mini Figures for Desk Decor & Classroom Rewards

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

NORCOOL LED drawing board front view with vibrant colors for creative doodling

NORCOOL

NORCOOL 16-Inch LED Drawing Board Rechargeable Light Up Pad

$19.84

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Gemscream 50-piece sea otter figurines set for playful decor and gifting.

Gemscream

Gemscream 50 Pcs Positive Mini Sea Otter Figurines – Motivational Desk Decor & Gift Set

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Generic fidget keyboard keychain with LED lights for portable focus.

Generic

Generic 4-Pack Fidget Keyboard Keychain Toy with LED Lights | Portable Stress-Relief Clicker

$24.85

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Kinetic Sand Project Planet Deep Sea shell scoop for imaginative ocean exploration

Kinetic Sand

Kinetic Sand Project Planet Deep Sea – 24oz Sensory Sand Kit & Sea Creature Tools (Eco Friendly)

$18.66

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Gemscream color your own dessert magnets donut design for fridge decoration and kids' crafting fun.

Gemscream

Gemscream Color Your Own Dessert Magnets – 30 Pcs DIY Kids Craft Kit

$20.80

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

3 Otters wind-up chicks 12-pack for Easter eggs hunts and party favors

3 otters

3 Otters Wind Up Chicks – 12-Pack Colorful Plush Easter Toys for Baskets & Party Favors

$20.80

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

KaKeDuJa metal brain teaser set for family challenges and mental flexibility

KaKeDuJa

KaKeDuJa 6-Piece Metal Brain Teaser Puzzles – Mind Challenge Gift Set

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

BePuzzled Eagle Deluxe completed 3D Crystal Puzzle displayed on a shelf to inspire conversation.

Bepuzzled

BePuzzled Eagle Deluxe 3D Crystal Puzzle – Challenging Interlocking Display (Ages 12+)

$19.70

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

ZURU Love Fuggs S2 Red Annoyed Alien front view, ideal display piece with signature button eyes.

ZURU

ZURU Fuggler Love Fuggs S2 Red Annoyed Alien – Collectible Plush Toy

$19.44

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

NINOSTAR squishy balls set with multicolor patterns for creative play

NINOSTAR

NINOSTAR Squishy Balls Set – Stress Relief Fidget Toys for Kids & Adults | Focus, Play & Decor

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Klever Kits Princess Diamond Art Set: engaging craft activity for imaginative kids.

Klever Kits

Klever Kits Gem Princess Diamond Art Kit: 16 Projects for Kids 6-12

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Generic Reflex Drop Sticks main pole setup enhances home play and coordination

Generic

Generic Reflex Drop Sticks Challenge Game – Hand-Eye Coordination & Reaction Training

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

LeapFrog 100 Animals Book pink cover, inviting tactile exploration for curious toddlers.

LeapFrog

LeapFrog 100 Animals Book (Frustration Free Packaging) – Pink | Bilingual English/Spanish

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

LeapFrog 100 Animals Book green front cover invites tactile exploration

LeapFrog

LeapFrog 100 Animals Book, Green – Bilingual Interactive Learning for Kids

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

THE BAMBINO TREE 100 First Words animals flash cards boost early vocabulary with bold animal images.

THE BAMBINO TREE

THE BAMBINO TREE 100 First Words Flash Cards – High-Contrast Picture Cards for Speech & Early Vocabulary

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

LADFAR Montessori Busy Book 8-page sensory exploration boosts hand-eye coordination during play

LADFAR

LADFAR Montessori Busy Book for Toddlers | 8-Page Sensory Activity & Fine Motor Skills | Portable Travel Toy (Blue)

$20.80

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Hagusahuo Shark Cat Plush full view with blue removable hood for cuddly play

Hagusahuo

Hagusahuo Shark Cat Plush – 8-Inch Plush with Removable Blue Shark Hood | Cute Kawaii Stuffed Animal Toy

$24.91

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Coodoo Unicorn Hatching Rainbow Eggs six-pack ready for imaginative play and discovery

Coodoo

Coodoo Unicorn Hatching Rainbow Eggs – 6-Pack Unicorn Craft Kits for Kids 3+ | Easter & Birthday Gifts

$22.17

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Vroomix Jova monster truck pack for toddlers with durable, colorful designs

Vroomix

Vroomix Jova 3-Pack Monster Truck Toys – Friction-Powered Pull-Back Cars

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

LEGO Creator 3-in-1 retro gaming console front view highlights display-ready build and imaginative play.

LEGO

LEGO Creator 3-in-1 Retro Gaming Console (31380) – Build 3 Toys in 1 Set

$23.32

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

Galison Michael Storrings Cats in the City puzzle shows a city garden scene for relaxed evenings.

Galison

Galison Michael Storrings Cats in the City 1000-Piece Puzzle | City Garden Artwork

$20.74

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

LEGO Minecraft Pale Garden tree assembly for creative building play.

LEGO

LEGO Minecraft The Pale Garden 21586 – Mothman, Creeper & Skeleton Minifigures (Ages 7+)

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

LEGO City Police Prisoner Transport Van front view for action-packed play

LEGO

LEGO City Police Prisoner Transport Van 60479 | Police Vehicle Toy for Kids 6+

$23.54

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

LEGO Fierce Dinosaur Velociraptor with movable joints for dynamic play

LEGO

LEGO Creator 3-in-1 Fierce Dinosaur Building Toy (31379) – 283 Pieces | 3 Dino Models for Kids Aged 8+

$23.48

Free shipping · Free 30-day returns

‹ 1 … 9 10 11 12 13 … 38 ›